Nov 10 work session (Watch / Agenda) · Nov 17 regular meeting (Watch / Agenda)
This recap was produced with AI assistance. Please email me to provide feedback.
The Oct 20 regular meeting is covered in the previous recap.
Highlight: WJCC Discipline Update
“On average, 24% of discipline referrals result in out-of-school suspensions. The data shows that we have not reduced our use of suspension, which means we have not met this [Key Performance Indicator].”
— Dr. Adam Brown, chief operating officer, 1:30:40
Watch: Nov 10 presentation, from 1:27:07 · Nov 10 discussion, from 1:51:58 · Nov 17 board comments, from 50:14 · packet
Nov 10: the presentation
The update grew out of a board request for more discipline data when the strategic plan’s indicators were presented in September (1:27:22). Dr. Adam Brown, the chief operating officer, and Mr. Nick Kier, supervisor of student services and intervention, presented.
The goal: under the strategic plan, “the overall percentage of behavioral referrals that results in suspensions from school will decrease by two percent” each year — Dr. Brown, 1:30:10
Rising incidents: over three years, “the share of students with at least one discipline incident rose from 12.3 to 15.2 percent” — Dr. Brown, 1:31:15
Students with disabilities: “Students receiving special education services made up 16 to 17 percent of enrollment, but 24 to 28 percent of students with incidents.” — Dr. Brown, 1:31:19
Black students: “black students are disproportionately represented. There are about 18% of our enrollment, but 36% of students disciplined and 44% of students who received out-of-school suspension.” — Dr. Brown, 1:33:27
Elementary schools: “Our elementary schools have the fewest referrals, yet a referral at that level is the most likely to result in an out-of-school suspension.” — Dr. Brown, 1:32:23. Middle and high schools have more in-school options, such as an in-school suspension coordinator and alternative classroom settings (1:33:05).
More behavior specialists: “This year, the team expanded to six specialists” (1:45:37). In the first quarter, “teachers and administrators submitted 80 requests” (1:46:16) and “the team completed 421 school and classroom visits” (1:46:29) — Mr. Kier
“I do not buy that Black students are twice as bad as white students and white students are twice as good - that’s just not the case. It’s just who gets picked.”
— Andrea Donnor, board chair 2:04:12
Nov 17: the board discussion
Mr. Hosang (45:50) took issue with remarks at the work session:
“We have unanimously sustained every case brought before us, with the majority of those students being black students. So this board, by last week’s perspective, is racist.” — 51:36, followed by “I don’t believe any of that.” (51:50)
“Other studies recently show that disciplinary issues are more prevalent in homes with a single parent” (52:47), and “Of that 21% of white families with children have a single parent. 79% of black families with children have a single parent.” (53:15)
“it’s a societal issue that is beyond the school system issue at this time.” — 53:45
Mrs. Donnor, in response (1:02:29):
“What was described earlier, it has a name, it’s called systemic racism and institutional racism.” — 1:02:50
“at no point last week was anyone in this body called racist. What was called out was numbers.” — 1:04:43
“52 percent of our enrolled population is white, but they only get 27% of out-of-school suspensions. And 18% of our enrollment is black, and they get 44%.” — 1:05:22
Mrs. Donnor described a school visit where a Black first or second grader raised her hand and “that teacher ignored her four times and she called on other children” (1:06:33): “Do I think that particular teacher was racist and trying to be racist? Absolutely not. But who did she see in that classroom and who did she pay attention to and who did she ignore?” — 1:08:12
“I challenge us to continue to have these conversations” — 1:12:31
Also this month: FY28 Budget Priorities
“We’re currently projecting these identified cost alone exceed our anticipated revenue growth … by approximately $800,000- and that’s before considering any other needs that may come forward as we continue developing the budget.”
— Rene Ewing, chief financial officer, 3:16:27
Watch: Nov 10 work session, from 3:13:12 · packet
The gap: revenue for the year starting July 1, 2027 is projected at $208.7 million, up about $4.8 million (3:14:35). Two costs already planned total about $5.6 million (3:16:20): year three of the compensation study, about $3.4 million (3:15:42), and pre-K at full capacity, 35 positions for about $1.9 million plus $300,000 to operate (3:16:08).
Three priorities, from staff’s one-on-one meetings with members: employee pay (3:17:02); student achievement and support, such as early-grade class sizes, counselors and small-group tutoring (3:17:59); and the operating costs of expanded career and technical education (3:18:51). Members said the list matched what they had asked for (3:20:21).
Next: a budget overview Dec 8 (3:22:30) and a pre-budget public hearing Jan 19 (3:22:48). On Nov 17 the board voted 7-0 to move the Capital Improvement Plan later, so it can reflect the new attendance zones: presented Jan 5, public hearing Jan 19, adoption Feb 2 (packet).Also this month: WJCC United Transition Roadmap
Also this month: WJCC United Transition Roadmap
Watch: Nov 10 presentation, from 2:20:39 · Nov 10 discussion, from 2:32:32 · packet
Staff’s monthly update on moving students into the attendance zones the board approved Oct 20 following the redistricting process. For how the zones were drawn, see the September, Oct 6 and Oct 20 recaps.
Letters to every family: “Paper notification letters will be mailed and emails will be sent out to all families regardless of whether their child will be changing schools.” — Kara Wall, chief communications officer, 2:26:11
Early December: families whose school changes get “an initial welcome email from their child’s future principal” — Ms. Wall, 2:26:27
January: curriculum fairs for middle school (Jan 13) and high school (Jan 14) at Warhill High School (2:29:38), and welcome nights for new families (2:29:59)
Rising seniors: families who chose in September to stay or move will be asked “to affirm their selection” — Ms. Wall, 2:31:45
Most students stay put: “it’s 85 percent that are not necessarily having to move” — Ms. Chen, 2:39:07
Public comment
Nine people spoke during public comment on Nov 17. Two raised the Nov 10 discipline data, listed here; the other topics follow under More Public Comment.
Speaker #2 (16:11): “it needs a detailed measurable action plan, not another round of acknowledgement” (16:51)
Speaker #9 (31:25): “This board must explain to the community what is driving that disparity” (32:04)
More Public Comment
Renaming James Blair Middle School
Speaker #1 (14:35): “It’s time to put it on the agenda and bring it to a vote.” (15:22)
Speaker #3 (18:30): “Please put this back on the agenda.” (20:06)
Speaker #5 (23:06): “without James Blair William and Mary would not be the school that it is today” (24:30)
Speaker #9 (31:25): “Why does a public school continue to honor an enslaver?” (32:49)
Early reading
Speaker #4 (20:24): “I want to speak about literacy” (20:37)
Speaker #5 (23:06): “Who is accountable in WJCC leadership for … reading programs” (23:32)
Speaker #6 (25:18): “A third grade reading promotion standard” (27:11)
A teacher’s conduct at the October meeting
William & Mary mentoring partnership
Board comments
Two members answered the James Blair speakers at the end of the Nov 17 meeting:
Mr. Riffle: “I also want to speak to some of the comments we’ve heard tonight that maybe glorify a bit of white privilege in our community.” (59:20) “It’s a little sad every time we have the mention of renaming that we have folks who want to glorify the Confederacy or glorify the actions of an institution that, you know, inherently built racism in America.” (59:26) “I think there’s maybe a surge amongst the community to revisit this, and I’m not going to promise anything beyond that” (59:52)
Mrs. Donnor (chair): “We can’t escape the name on our building of James Blair and what that symbolizes and what that means for students who are walking in that door every day, our descendant community students.” (1:12:19)
Other Agenda Items
Votes on Nov 17, each reviewed at the Nov 10 work session — all approved 7-0, every member present:
Updated 2026-2027 Textbook Selection and Adoption Proposal — adds World Languages (Spanish and German, levels I–IV and AP) to the CTE and math adoptions; projected costs $15,000 (CTE), $475,000 (math) and $400,000 (World Languages) — packet
Secondary Program of Studies 2027-2028 — packet
Amendment to the FY27 Grants Fund Budget, up $557,956 to $7,858,804 for a USDA Farm to School grant ($499,956) and a Kiwanis Club–Otter Cove grant ($58,000) — packet
Amendment to the FY28 Budget Calendar, moving the Capital Improvement Plan dates (see above) — packet / calendar
Policies, approved 7-0 as part of the consent agenda: BDD, GAH, GCBEA, GCN, KA, KAB and KKA
Also approved 7-0 on Nov 17:
The rest of the consent agenda, in the same vote: the October financial report and bills (packet) and the Oct 20 minutes
Personnel Actions
Minutes of the Nov 10 work session
Nov 10 votes:
Approval of Personnel Actions — Approved 6-0
Approval of Decision Regarding Parent Appeal Record Review, Case #2627-010 — the board upheld the division’s disciplinary decision, 6-0
Upcoming Meetings
VSBA Annual Convention (the board attends)
Nov 18–20, all day
The Williamsburg Lodge, 310 S England Street, Williamsburg
Work Session
Capital Improvement Plan: presented Jan 5, 2027, with a public hearing Jan 19, under the calendar the board approved Nov 17
How to participate: Public comment is taken at the regular meeting only, not at the work session. Speakers must sign up before the meeting begins. Each speaker may have 2 minutes to address the School Board.
Contact the board: The school boardmember’s contact information is listed on the division’s School Board page.

